I can somewhat agree to this. I'm 95% sure since Loyalty Shop was done and released (Before Imagine's Time), that it has never been altered. I wouldn't like to see the rewards you listed. Maybe some osrs cosmetic sets (Like Angler Set, Increasing fishing experience by xx - Prospector Set, Increasing mining experience by xx), New loyalty Titles, New custom pets (With new unique rewards), Making use of the features tab to buy perks (Increased chance at items from thieving, Increased chance at imp points while training hunter...etc), and Making use of the Aura's tab (Maybe add some aura's that go into the trophy slot, with decent combat bonuses. This would make use of the trophy slot, and be less hassle as no trophies need to be made this way).